Is My Balcony Safe?

[vc_row width=”70″ background_image=””][vc_column][sapphire_textBlock]Is my balcony safe? What if a fire starts? What if it’s been installed incorrectly?

These are all questions our end-users will reasonably have living in a high-rise residential unit and as architects, developers, manufacturers, suppliers and installers, the onus is on all involved to justify, explain and reassure the end-user that their property, their home, is safe to live in.

In this article, we’ll be exploring the scope of making a balcony safe, from the design choices we make, to the materials used, to necessary maintenance and beyond. We’ll look into fire risks, drainage and how both are mitigated against through smart balcony design.

The safety of end-users and residents should be our number-one priority. Let’s look into how to make a balcony safe.

Materials used

A key principle of architecture is balance. Balancing the desire for attractive design with the crucial need for strong, safe construction. To ensure this type of strong and safe construction, there are three key areas to focus on from an early stage, looking at the materials used.

Firstly, designing for the long term. Sapphire’s balconies are typically designed to meet a 60-year lifecycle thanks to the aluminium we use in the construction of our balcony Cassettes. Aluminium is a strong material with flexible design possibilities, making it perfect for the extrusion of different types and shapes of balustrading. Critical Connections back to the building will normally be made of M30 stainless steel. The size means the are much more robust, both because of them being over engineered for a much stronger resistance to the moment forces and because of the corrosion resistance of stainless steel.[/sapphire_textBlock][sapphire_textOverlayBlock image=”460″ heading=”Sapphire’s One-Stop Suspension Solution” button_text=”Read more” button_link=”url:https%3A%2F%2Fwww.resi.build%2Fpost%2Fsapphires-one-stop-suspension-solution” double_height=””]Learn more about how Sapphire splits out their anchors and stubs to create a safer connection.[/sapphire_textOverlayBlock][/vc_column][/vc_row][vc_row width=”70″ background_image=””][vc_column css=”.vc_custom_1707736247028{padding-bottom: 10px !important;}”][sapphire_textBlock]Using material like timber or concrete is not a wise choice as the material cannot endure time, nor the elements. We’ve seen in recent months that timber will degrade over time – this fundamentally misses the spirit of construction design and management (CDM) regulations. Using a material that will maintain its integrity for the entirety of its lifespan should be a priority. With aluminium, this can be achieved with relative ease as it does not rust or degrade over time.

Finally, the material choice should always be non-combustible. In the UK this is mandatory on taller buildings under Part B of the Building Regulations. In other markets where this is not mandatory, the guidance should still be followed to ensure the absolute safety of the end-user. By using non-combustible materials, unnecessary fire risk or spread can be avoided.

Construction methods

The next step to ensuring balcony safety is through the methods of construction. Thanks to modern methods of construction (MMC), construction is more flexible and innovative than ever so safety can be more readily assured, so long as the correct methods are used.

Connecting a balcony mechanically is the simplest way to ensure connection safety. Historically, adhesives have been used a lot on building façade to stick components together, but this can be a risk. At Sapphire, we choose to mechanically fix components to the building façade through arm connected with stainless steel bolts, which do not lose their structural integrity like adhesives could and are easier to control the correct torque settings have been achieved, whereas an adhesive done correctly can be difficult to confirm, is more dependent on competence and expierience of the applicator and may become lose over time or in extreme heat or cold.

The competency of process and people should also be considered here. Like cars, controlled manufacturing envrionments with the right processes mean that prefab balconies should be inherently safer. Offsite manufacture must be tightly controlled with safety procedures and quality control in place at every step of the process. Throughout our history we have continually reduced the dependence of site labour and site conditions by designing more of the production to be carried out in factories. We manufacture our balconies offsite, monitoring each stage of the production with our Passport® app. We have also introduced a learning management system (LMS), which allows us to monitor and ensure the training, competency and compliance of all our workers. This enables a single balcony to then be traced back to which factory, which date, which operative and what thier training records were at that point. The passport app has continually been expanded and advanced to enable the collection of more and more data and imagery of the production process.

Finally, minimising the dependence on an individual’s competency is crucial for balcony safety. At Sapphire, we believe in ensuring that our staff are competent and continually learning, but this alone is not enough. High dependence on the skill of a single labourer is a potential risk area and so is assembly done on sites where there is other factors which could influence. By simplifying the product junctions and making sure the system itself is as risk-averse as possible, we further avoid the risk of workers relying on a single staff member’s competency. As an example, by having all welds double-checked independently and by using witness marks on connection bolts, we can quickly determine if bolts have been torqued correctly or if key connections have been tampered with, both measures which support the delivery of product which is not only of good quality but is also up to the high safety standard our clients and Sapphire expect.

Fire risk

As mentioned above, fire risk is an important consideration for balcony manufacturers as well as construction developers. To avoid another disaster like that at Grenfell Tower in 2017, we must take steps to mitigate against fire spread. This can involve better choice of materials and discouragement of fire risks for our end-users.

Material selection is key. We spoke with Kevan Brelsford of the Manchester Fire & Rescue team and he summarised the need for better material selection. Using flame-retardant, non-combustible furnishings is crucial. The need for this may seem obvious in a post-Grenfell world, but it needs to be reiterated. Furthermore, minimising ignition sources can be the difference between safety and danger as “more or less anything will burn in the right circumstances”, so reducing the opportunity for fire to start and/or spread is key.

Watch the full video with Kevan Brelsford speaking on behalf of the Manchester Fire & Rescue team to learn more about fire risk:

 

[/sapphire_textBlock][/vc_column][/vc_row][vc_row width=”70″ background_image=””][vc_column][sapphire_textBlock]

Drainage methods

Water ingress has been a key challenge in most markets the balcony markets we work in globally.

In markets like New Zealand, we’ve seen the ‘leaky homes’ crisis, where timber-framed homes built primarily in the 1990s were not properly protected against the weather. These drainage problems have in some instances made the timber framing structurally unstable and so unfit to live inside. We’ve seen similar issues in the Canadian market and so the need for structurally sound homes, protected against water ingress, is key.

The key principle of drainage is that the nearest point of water collection needs to be as far from the building threshold as possible. Collection of water should, in no circumstances allow for a build-up. Finally taking water away from the building is much better principle than back towards a building.

To mitigate against this, materials should be considered, as well as direction of drainage and number of drainage points.

Corrosion-resistant materials such as aluminium should be used. Timber should never be used as a drainage material due to its susceptibility to rotting. Draining away from the building in 400mm sections is a method that Sapphire uses – our edge draining solution (as it is known in balcony standard BS 8579:2020) uses multiple points of drainage through integrated soffits in order to disperse water efficiently and safely without the need for fixed rear drainage pipes.

Maintenance

Balcony maintenance should be simple to carry out, regular and thorough.

A balcony left to fester amongst the elements, no matter the material used to construct it, can be at risk of the averse effects of ageing. Maintenance should therefore be carried out whenever necessary and, where possible, regularly scheduled.

Balconies should be designed with maintenance in mind. Urgent maintenance should not require scaffolds to be set up and so balconies should be designed to be maintained from the apartment they belong to.

At Sapphire, we design our balconies in this way. As an example, a balcony can have its decking raised to view the soffits below, meaning essential maintenance can be carried out both quickly and thoroughly to avoid incidence.

Conclusion

Understanding the risk that comes with construction and ongoing use of balconies is of the utmost importance. Balcony manufacturers and suppliers must make sure their products are safe on delivery, safe to install and safe for the end user over its entire design life.

We use aluminium construction due to its structural rigidity, improved safety aspects when compared to a traditional concrete alternative, integrated drainage system to reduce risk of water ingress, its non combustible properties and the wide variety of secure connection possibilities that can be chosen depending on the project at hand.

When asking the question; “is my balcony safe?” – it takes analysis of all risk areas, research and development and a competent team to supply an answer. If you are moving into a new property and you are lucky enough to have a Sapphire balcony, we certainly believe that our ethical approach to balcony design combined with our rigorous testing regimes and quality systems do mean that you are in a safe pair of hands with Sapphire.

To learn more about making your balcony safe, we’ve provided links to whitepapers, CPDs and articles published by Sapphire below.[/sapphire_textBlock][sapphire_textOverlayBlock image=”11006″ heading=”Balcony Fire Safety Whitepaper” button_text=”Download” button_link=”title:Fire%20Safety%20Whitepaper” double_height=””]Regulations, research and testing, available in our whitepaper.[/sapphire_textOverlayBlock][sapphire_textOverlayBlock image=”13767″ heading=”Balcony Fires CPD” button_text=”Request now” button_link=”url:http%3A%2F%2Flocalhost%2Fbalconies%2Fknowledge%2Fcpd-presentations%2Fbalcony-fires-cpd%2F|title:Balcony%20Fires%20CPD” double_height=””]Request our balcony fires CPD – learn about common causes and reduce risk.[/sapphire_textOverlayBlock][sapphire_textOverlayBlock image=”12657″ heading=”Balcony Drainage” button_text=”Read more” button_link=”url:http%3A%2F%2Flocalhost%2Fbalconies%2Four-product%2Fframe-deck-soffits%2Fsoffits%2Fbalcony-drainage%2F” double_height=””]All you need to know about balcony drainage.[/sapphire_textOverlayBlock][sapphire_textOverlayBlock image=”13768″ heading=”Balcony Materials, Maintenance & Lifespan” button_text=”Read more” button_link=”url:http%3A%2F%2Flocalhost%2Fbalconies%2Fknowledge%2Fmaterial-maintenance-and-sustainability%2F” double_height=””]Learn more about how to choose balcony materials on our dedicated page.[/sapphire_textOverlayBlock][/vc_column][/vc_row][vc_row width=”70″ background_image=”” el_id=”” el_class=”” css=””][vc_column][vc_raw_html]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[/vc_raw_html][/vc_column][/vc_row]

Pain points of concrete balconies

[vc_row width=”70″ background_image=””][vc_column][sapphire_textBlock]Innovation is the means by which we travel from tradition to modernization. It’s a vehicle for removing stagnation and arriving at vibrance.

Traditionally, balconies have been built with reinforced concrete (RC), a material that can be cast on-site and last for decades. But as time moves on, the construction industry discovers improved methods of manufacturing and the old concrete ages, the question needs to be asked: are concrete balconies still worth your time?

Various pain points of concrete can be avoided through the use of modern aluminium balconies such as the saving of time and money or the increase in safety that comes with it. We’ve delved into how concrete has become outdated and how aluminium could be your future material.

Concrete’s loss of aesthetic value

Whilst the aesthetic intention of a concrete balcony is an incredibly clean fascia, concrete can easily be damaged during its installation, so this is not always achievable. As concrete is infamously hard to work around, concrete is susceptible to aesthetic damage over time. In cold snaps, cracks can form in concrete regardless of weather protection and colour can fade over time, leading to a resident’s balcony looking less like a relaxing outdoor living space and more like an unkempt highway.[/sapphire_textBlock][sapphire_imageBlock image=”11704″ notch=”” height=””][/sapphire_imageBlock][/vc_column][/vc_row][vc_row width=”70″ background_image=””][vc_column][sapphire_textBlock]The loss of aesthetic value can detract from the value of the apartment (or even the building as a whole) over time. To maintain a good level of aesthetic value (with the added benefit of broader customization options), aluminum balconies are an intelligent choice. Sapphire’s aluminum balconies are more strongly protected against the weather and are guaranteed to last 60 years. Furthermore, they are easily cleaned and simple to repair, giving them huge longevity over concrete.

The issues with installing concrete balconies

Concrete balcony installation is time-consuming, easily mismanaged and can cause extreme delays due to the nature of casting on-site.

Casting balconies with reinforced concrete can lead to a number of issues, notably the opportunity for mismeasured connections. Traditional casting can over or under-fit the frame meaning re-casting needs to be observed. Furthermore, a continuous thermal break needs to be installed when casting in concrete, leading to extra time on site and further inflated costs.

Aluminum balconies are fit with measured templates and anchors cast into the façade. This means aluminum balconies should always fit the first time and avoid misalignment issues common with bolt-on methods.

Are concrete balconies more expensive?

Interfacing costs and issues associated with concrete balconies can make concrete a far more expensive material to work with than the aluminum alternative. In most cases, concrete balconies can inflate the cost of a project and cause extensive issues down the line.

Concrete balconies necessitate always having multiple trades on-site, causing unnecessary confusion, delays and adding costs due to the number of staff needed. The extra costs associated with drainage in concrete balconies can make concrete construction inordinately expensive.

Using aluminum balconies can elegantly reduce (or even remove) these extra costs. By using controlled edge drainage with our smart soffits, the need for fixed drainage is removed. Aluminum balconies can use Sapphire’s iconic Glide-On system to install quickly, easily and with minimal oversight. Finally, aluminum is a cheaper material by weight than concrete and can be assembled off-site, meaning less time and staff are needed on-site for your project.

This brings us back to the initial question: are concrete balconies still worth your time? Given the extensive pain points of concrete, we at Sapphire believe that concrete has had its day and it’s time for an innovative new material to take its place. Concrete is susceptible to all manner of woes, from aesthetic loss over time, to tricky installation, to inflated costs when more sensible options are available.

Mass customizability

Innovative balconies are more than just future-proof, sustainable technical design – the mass customizability of balconies is a benefit that goes beyond aesthetic value.

Digital balcony configuration has become a staple of Sapphire’s innovation with our COACH system – giving our customers the ability to easily visualise their ideal balcony project without the rigour of having to hire a design professional first. Once your balcony has been configured, COACH lets you send the design to our dedicated pre-construction team who will guide you through making your design a reality.

Between the customization of balustrades (vertical, rotated and inclined bars), drainage options available (controlled edge or rear pipe drainage) and methods of installation, it’s never been easier to make your balcony project unique to you.

By switching to aluminum, you can avoid the pain points of concrete and extend the life of your balcony project with ease. For more information on the differences between the two materials, read more here:[/sapphire_textBlock][sapphire_textOverlayBlock image=”12004″ heading=”Aluminum vs. Concrete Balconies” button_text=”Read more” button_link=”url:http%3A%2F%2Flocalhost%2Fbalconies%2Fknowledge%2Faluminium-concrete-balconies%2F|title:Read%20more|target:_blank” double_height=””]How does aluminum compare to traditional concrete? We’ve prepared this knowledge hub so you can expand what you know and make an informed decision on aluminum balconies.[/sapphire_textOverlayBlock][/vc_column][/vc_row]

Aluminium vs Composite Board

It’s not uncommon that a resident would want to use their balcony as soon as it’s finished being installed. But until the decking is installed, that reality isn’t possible. Therefore, choosing a suitable decking early on is key. Since the Hackitt review and following the ban on combustible cladding, the industry has been looking for a way to make all decking class A fire rated. Historically, decking was made from either wood panelling or a mineral board but now the market has changed, and the core argument is this: Aluminium vs Composite Board.

Variety of products

Sapphire is the proud supplier of our partner MyDek’s range of non-combustible decking options. Aluminium options such as Delta, Vista or Innova are all available. The Delta range can be fixed directly to steel balcony frames and allows lightning-fast installation. The Vista is MyDek’s original high-performance decking board with a classic appearance, attached via clip-fixing. Finally, the Innova board is available in a range of colours, all providing a compliant, economic solution for any non-combustible decking needs.

After a partnership of the teams at MyDek and Blazeboard, and several years of careful development, the team at MyDek released Luxura. Made from a composite mineral board, Luxura is a class A fire-rated decking option, available for both decking and paving. The decking, which comes in both 150- and 200-mm width formats, is fixable to aluminium subframe systems or steel framed balconies and uses a concealed system of fixing clips and screws.

Resistance testing

All decking is resistance assessed under various conditions, such as heat, scratch, sound, and stress. Since the Hackitt review and subsequent ban on combustible cladding, all decking must be non-combustible and Class A fire rated. Decking must be slip-resistant and ideally, fall within a score of 36 or higher when evaluated against the Pendulum Test Value (PTV).

Whilst incredibly durable, composite decking is notoriously prone to scratching and scuffing. With this said, however, scratches and scuffs on composite decking are easily fixed. Using fine 60-grit sandpaper along the length of the decking will remove any appearance of a scratch after a period of weathering naturally.

Aluminium decking is three times stronger than composite decking and yet much lighter than composite, making it much easier to install. However, composite decking is much more malleable, making it easier to customise.

Carbon benefits

There are several benefits to choosing either aluminium or mineral board on your decking when it comes to reducing your carbon footprint.

Composite decking can be made from recycled plastics, wood or aluminium and so requires minimal fabrication of raw material. This reduces the embodied carbon present in the material which is great for the environment. Composite decking is free of toxic chemicals and requires less deforestation for its production than traditional wood decking.

Aluminium decking has a long life of over 30 years and so does not need to be replaced as often, both making it better for the environment and more financially viable long term. Furthermore, aluminium can be recycled infinitely without losing its quality, making it a highly sustainable option.

Reducing the embodied carbon in your decking can help the environment to a huge degree and reduce your carbon footprint before the decking is installed.

When making your decision about what type of decking to go for, aluminium vs composite board is an argument worth having – whether one has a significant advantage over the other. The truth is that both have their benefits. There is a great deal of variety at hand for both types of decking, the resistance testing on both is always kept to exceptional quality and either option has a hand in reducing your carbon footprint.

To learn more about the types of decking available, check out MyDek’s website.

Furthermore, if you’d like to see the sustainability benefits of using aluminium or composite board decking in your balcony, try our free design tool COACH.

Steel Vs Aluminium Balconies

The mandatory usage of non-combustible materials in the external envelope of the high-rise building, coupled with the drive for Net Zero and offsite construction has led to a steep trend towards the metal balcony manufacturers. More and more developers and architects had to choose between Steel and Aluminium for their next project. So, the battle between Steel vs Aluminium is on the rise.

Both these metals have strong qualities. But, if you are mulling over picking which metal to use for your next project, then here is a detailed analysis of these products regarding fire, strength, durability, cost, and sustainability.

Fire

Following the Hackett Review, new regulations clearly state that all materials must be certified EuroClass A1 or A2- s1, d0 ratings. The good news is that both these metals achieve a Class A1 rating.

While Steel has a higher melting point (about 40% higher than aluminium), the thermal conductivity of Aluminium is four times higher than Steel. The heat is dispersed faster, and a more significant amount of heat is required to heat Aluminium to a given temperature compared to Steel. The higher thermal conductivity of Aluminium enables the heat to conduct away, prolonging the endurance of an Aluminium structure in a fire. Both are good options for the core structure of a balcony.

Providing no contribution to heat, Aluminium and steel easily achieve the EuroClass A1 standard. Both metals can be powder coated with class A coatings, although Aluminium balconies can be coated to the renowned high standards set out in the Qualicoat standards. The critical thing with any coating applied to metal is that is done properly and prevents smoke emission and the production of ‘flaming droplets’.

Strength

Steel is a prime choice in many construction industries due to its strength. It is more robust than Aluminium; there is no denying that! Aluminium is one third the weight of steel.

It is for this very reason that many aluminium balconies utilise steel stubs and arms to support the balcony.

One of the greatest attributes of Aluminium is its strength to weight ratio, which means these balconies can be built at the same strength as two-thirds the weight of a Steel balcony.

So steel offers a strong, heavy balcony Cassette however it is also its weakness from a strength point of view because of the need for more anchors to take the additional forces, whereas the light weight of aluminium means less connections are necessary.

Durability

Due to its tensile strength, Steel is stronger;  but that does not make it resistant to corrosion, in fact, Steel rusts quickly without proper treatment. Aluminium, on the other hand, is corrosion resistant. Steel rusts and aluminium doesn’t. When exposed to a moist, damp or abrasive environment, there is a higher chance of rust eating away Steel.

It is a matter of resistance that prolongs the life of the metal. Whist proper galvanising can be achieved aluminium doesn’t need any form of additional protection.

Cost

The cost of both these metals keeps fluctuating based on the global supply and demand. However, steel is a lot cheaper compared to Aluminium per tonne of metal. But, keeping in mind the strength to weight ratio, that same tonne goes a lot further in terms of meters meaning that comparable balconies are similar in price either way, although if anchors and Cassettes are designed together it may be possible to optimise the balcony connections and slab thicknesses to save considerable money because of the aluminium weight advantage.

Malleability

Aluminium is more malleable and elastic when compared to Steel. Aluminium can be bent and easily shaped to form intricate designs. Steel, however, is tough and is a resilient metal and cannot be pushed to the same dimensional limits as Aluminium.

Sustainability

Both are metals meaning that they both have a lot of embodied carbon in the process of either creation of virgin material or recycling. Steel has a lower initial footprint per ton however it is not as a renewable resource. The amount of energy needed to recycle Steel is a lot higher when compared to Aluminium. It is highly recyclable, and it retains its property indefinitely.

When comparing it is important to look at the embodied carbon per balcony not per tonne as this will give an accurate picture.

Installation

A few critical factors like transport and crane lifting have to be considered for installation. Steel is a heavyweight metal making it complex for transportation and installation. Being a lightweight metal, Aluminium makes transportation and installation a lot easier.

Additionally, the speed of installation of Aluminium balconies is a lot faster than Steel balconies meaning less labour and quicker programs.

To conclude, both these metals are equally good in many respects. But, if we had to pick a winner, considering the characteristics and the application of the metal, we believe Aluminium to be a better choice for our balcony Cassettes and a hybrid of Steel arms and Stainless steel anchors for the connection.